I Lost My Pillow (and My Sanity)
How one destroyed pillow unraveled my sleep, my spine, and my understanding of habits.
You never really know what’s holding your life together until it’s gone.
For some people, it’s their morning coffee.
For others, it’s their therapist.
For me? It was a flat pillow.
Not a fancy orthopedic memory foam situation. Not a cooling gel cube infused with lavender oil and NASA technology. Just a flat, floppy, unglamorous pillow I had slept on for over a decade.
It had no right to be as important as it was.
But it was everything.
And then one day on a family vacation, it vanished. I can’t even tell you how. Maybe it got shoved into a hotel laundry cart. Maybe it disintegrated from sheer exhaustion. Maybe it just gave up on me. Either way, it was gone.
And I—high-functioning adult that I am—spiraled.
The Great Pillow Spiral of Shame
You think you’re fine until you’re not. That first night, I laid my head on the hotel pillow, which had the fluff-to-support ratio of a deflated marshmallow, and instantly knew: this was war.
My neck was the first to protest. Then my shoulders. Then my entire sleep routine. Nights turned into a series of tosses, turns, groans, stretches, and desperate punches to fluff the fluffless.
I tried everything.
Foam pillows, feather pillows, buckwheat pillows that sounded like I was sleeping on a bag of birdseed. I tried stacking two, folding one, sleeping without any. One was so firm it felt like cuddling a sandbag. Another was so plush my head disappeared into it like quicksand.
I spent more money on pillows in a month than most people spend on skincare in a year.
It got comical.
My family would see a new Amazon box and say, “Is that another pillow?”
Yes. Yes it was.
The Habit Hidden in the Fluff
Eventually, I found a replacement. Not identical—because lost loves can’t be replaced, only reinvented—but close enough.
And here’s the weird part. Once I had the right pillow again, sleep came easy. Like nothing had ever happened. Like my body said, “Ah, finally, we’re back.” All the effort, the experimenting, the money, the frustration—gone.
Which made me realize: it wasn’t about the pillow. Not really.
It was about the system.
That pillow had become a silent, steady part of my sleep ritual. A cue. A signal to my nervous system: “Hey, we’re safe now. You can relax.” It had trained my body to expect sleep.
When it disappeared, so did the cue. My whole system went searching for a new pattern. And until it found one, everything felt off.
The Science of the Stupid Pillow
I tell you this not because I want to start a side hustle reviewing bedding (although I probably could at this point). I tell you this because the same thing is happening all over your life, in ways you may not realize.
We tend to think habits are about effort and motivation.
They’re not.
They’re about cues. Environment. Sensory anchors. The little, invisible things your brain uses to automate comfort.
That’s why people struggle with change. Not because they’re weak. But because they’ve unknowingly trained their body to expect a certain outcome from a certain setup.
You crave chips not because you lack discipline, but because your brain associates the couch, the show, and the crinkle of the bag with relief.
You scroll your phone at night not because you’re irresponsible, but because your brain has learned that the glow of the screen is the cue to check out.
And maybe—just maybe—you can’t fall asleep because your favorite flat, ten-year-old pillow is gone and no one understands your pain.
So what’s the point of all this?
The point is:
Sometimes the most powerful thing you can do for your health is not try harder.
It’s to find your pillow.
That tiny environmental shift that makes everything easier. That cue your body trusts. That comforting little anchor that says, “Now we do the thing that makes us feel good.”
Sometimes it’s laying out your walking shoes the night before.
Sometimes it’s keeping the healthy food at eye level in the fridge.
Sometimes it’s texting a friend, so you don’t bail on your habit.
And sometimes, it’s just letting yourself be a little ridiculous about needing the right pillow.
Because healing isn’t about perfection.
It’s about designing your life so that good choices become automatic, and bad ones become inconvenient.
And that’s exactly what we do each week inside The Habit Healers Mindset’s Inner Circle. We don’t just talk about change—we design for it. We look for the friction. The fluff. The stuff that derails you. And we replace it with micro-adjustments that bring your nervous system back to ease.
We build new rituals, one soft landing at a time.
So, if you’ve been trying to change your habits and it’s felt hard, heavy, or like you’re sleeping on a bag of gravel—this is your sign.
Don’t get a new personality.
Get a new pillow.
Join The Inner Circle now.
Let’s rebuild your habits from the bottom up—flatter, softer, smarter.
You are one healing habit away…
Oh how this resonates beginning with my manic search for the perfect pillow which in the end turned out to buckwheat husk because I can mold it to my neck as I settle into my sacred spot, my own bed. Years of shift work, of single parenting and elder frail parents that meant what I gave up was the time I got to lie down. Women do this; give up sleep to meet others needs or to keep the wheels on. The minutes when first prone one tends to 'run the day' in one's head. I love Myra Anderson's advice to forgive your self and resolve to do better and shut down, tucking that perfect pillow into the curve of one's neck, stretching one's limbs and finding that initial sleep position that signals the day is over. We never get it all done. We never will but routines that restore one's mental, physical and spiritual foundation keep us keeping on.
It’s work sometimes to set up that gym bag the night before but it sure pushes me to go to the gym because it’s already packed.
My husband once found the perfect pillow at an AirBnb. I insisted we could just buy it on Amazon and would not let him steal it. That started our pillow ordering spree. Thankfully we found one eventually that was just right.