Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Georgia Patrick's avatar

Magnificent! The Marbas Manifesto on Medicine and Healing. I've studied manifestos as long as you've practiced medicine. The challenge always has been how to move hearts and minds to make this their manifesto. My bias--I think every human needs to create their own manifesto and cover all seven areas of life. Health is one of those areas.

Famous manifestos: 1517 Ninety-Five Theses by Martin Luther on the Power and Efficacy of Indulgences. 1776 The Declaration of Independence. 1999 The Cluetrain Manifesto, which starts out "People of earth..."

Expand full comment
Sue Kusch's avatar

Yesterday, I met with a PA at my local clinic in a semi-rural area. I have been experiencing difficulty with my breathing - struggling with getting a deep breath. I had no other symptoms or related conditions and I had already researched anxiety as a possible cause.

I have been exceptionally anxious January. I am 66 and have done a lot of work on my self and I know that my chaotic and dysfunctionall childhood motivated me to create an adulthood based on feeling safe and secure. That now feels threatened by the current adminstration. I also have assumed control over my health, eating right, exercising, managing stress, incorporating herbs for remedies. Part of my weekly journaling includes a body and mind check-in.

I made the appt to rule out any other possible causes.

The PA, about 30 years younger than me, listened with a blank, non-responsive presence but she was practicing the "I am listening" professional demeanor. There was no empathy and at one point, when I expressed the fear and panic that I and most everyone I knew was experiencing, she interrupted me to say, "Trust me, not everyone is panicking."

That lack of empathy and arrogance reminded me of why I seldom go to my only clinic. She asked no questions, didn't bother to listen to my lungs, and recommended that I meet with a counselor so I could get "tools" to use. She never asked me what I was doing, if anything, to help with my anxiety. When I explained that I was doing she again recommended talk therapy.

This only confirmed, again, that I am just another insurance billing and that I can't turn to my only clinic for anything beyond lab work.

Thank you for this important post!

Expand full comment
46 more comments...

No posts